SC 3.x / Reservation / Volume Managers

Greetings experts,

would you please help me to acquire a better understanding:

1. In SC 3.0 and SC3.1 SCSI-3 PGR is used in a 3 nodes cluster for both, the DCS and the QD disks (in a 2 nodes cluster traditional SCSI-2 Reserve is used for DCS and PGRE for QD devices)

2. In SC 3.2 the same applies unless by specifiying it, SCSI-3 PGR can even be used in a two nodes environment.

Assumed we would have a cluster using SCSI-3 PGR (either item 1 or item 2 or both are fullfilled).

In a SC environment I can use SVM/SDS as volume manager. My understanding is that SVM/SDS knows "only" SCSI-2 and it seems that http://bugs.opensolaris.org/view_bug.do?bug_id=4827356 confirms my understanding.

What would that mean for the cluster in case of a situation in which reservation would take place: would we see two kinds of Reserves on the same disk: a) a SCSI-3 PGR (since the prereqs are fullfilled)plus b) a SCSI-2 Reserve since SVM/SDS knows "only" SCSI-2 Reserves?

And what about VxVM as volume manager?

Thanks hontoy

[1074 byte] By [hontoya] at [2007-11-27 8:37:50]
# 1

SVM/SDS is Sun Cluster aware, which means it knows if it is being used within Sun Cluster. And in that case SVM/SDS does not perform its logic for scsi reservation.

It does this only if run without Sun Cluster.

So there is no competition. If run with Sun Cluster, only DCS will perform the reservation.

For VxVM you need to check with Veritas/Semantic to get a definitive answer, but my understanding is it does not use scsi reservation at all.

Greets

Thorsten

Thorsten.Frueaufa at 2007-7-12 20:35:16 > top of Java-index,Solaris Operating System,Solaris Essentials - General Technical Questions...
# 2
Many thanks that you shed some light onto this item. I wasn't aware of this approach. It makes a lot of sense and therefore avoids double reservation or - as you are saying - some competition in terms of reservation.Once more many thanksCheers hontoy
hontoya at 2007-7-12 20:35:16 > top of Java-index,Solaris Operating System,Solaris Essentials - General Technical Questions...